| Platinum | Wing Madness |
| Gold | Oak Beach Bar and Grill |
| Silver | Christopher Martins |
| Bronze | Riptide |
| Top Pick | 116 Crown |
| Top Pick | 80 Proof American Kitchen & Bar |
| Top Pick | Anchor Spa |
| Top Pick | Elm City Social |
| Top Pick | Sandra's Next Generation |
| Top Pick | USA 1 Pizza |