| Platinum | Biagetti's |
| Gold | Lorenzo's Ristorante Italiano |
| Silver | Brazi's Italian Restaurant |
| Bronze | Il Gabbiano |
| Top Pick | Adriana's Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Carmine's Di Vega |
| Top Pick | Goodfellas Restaurant |
| Top Pick | L'Orcio |
| Top Pick | Mama Theresas |
| Top Pick | Zeneli Pizzeria |