| Platinum | Modern Apizza |
| Gold | Rosso Vino |
| Silver | Brazi's Italian Restaurant |
| Bronze | Camacho Garage |
| Top Pick | Breakwall |
| Top Pick | Cast Iron Chef Chop House & Oyster Bar |
| Top Pick | Gennaro's Pizza Pasta |
| Top Pick | L'Orcio |
| Top Pick | Nicky's Place Bar & Pizza in East Haven |
| Top Pick | Riptide |
| Pacifico Restaurant |