| Platinum | Modern Apizza |
| Gold | Sally's Apizza |
| Silver | Zuppardi's Apizza |
| Bronze | Ernie's Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Aladdin Crown Pizza |
| Top Pick | Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana |
| Top Pick | Frank Pepe's The Spot |
| Top Pick | Full Circle Pizza |
| Top Pick | Nicky's Place Bar & Pizza in East Haven |
| Top Pick | One6Three The Pizza Joint |